The 5 Interview Questions you keep answering wrong! — And how to ACTUALLY answer them.

Nov 17 / Sam Sperling
Picture this: You’re perfect on paper, but somehow the job keeps slipping away after the interview. It’s not your qualifications — it’s the way you’re answering critical questions that’s holding you back. The good news is, with a few tweaks, you can transform your answers and leave a lasting impression that lands you the job.

As seasoned hiring managers who’ve conducted hundreds of interviews, we’ve witnessed firsthand where candidates falter. We’ve seen talented individuals miss opportunities simply because of how they answer certain questions. Drawing from our extensive experience, we’re here to shed light on these pitfalls and guide you toward interview success.
HYBRID: THIS ARTICLE HAS BEEN Responsibly CO-written with AI

#1 “Tell me about yourself.”

What’s Behind the Question?

  • The manager wants to know if you’re approachable and relatable.
  • They’re assessing your ability to structure and communicate your story clearly.
  • They want to see if you’re a cultural fit and bring relevant experience.

Common Mistakes

  • Rambling Without Focus: Providing a long-winded life story that lacks relevance to the job.
  • Being Too Personal: Sharing private details that are inappropriate for a professional setting.
  • Reciting Your Resume: Repeating what’s already on your CV without adding personal insight.

How to Nail It

Use the Present-Past-Future Framework:
  • Present: Briefly describe your current role and relevant achievements.
  • Past: Highlight key experiences that shaped your skills for this role.
  • Future: Share why you’re excited about this opportunity and how you’ll contribute.
Be Specific and Tailored:
Focus on experiences and traits that align with the job. Avoid rambling or generic overviews.

Let Your Personality Shine:
A touch of enthusiasm and authenticity goes a long way.

#2 “Why do you want to work here?”

What’s Behind the Question?

  • They want to see if you’ve done your homework and genuinely connect with the company’s mission.
  • The manager is assessing your motivation and whether you’ll be a good cultural fit.
  • They’re also testing how well you understand the role and its challenges.

Common Mistakes

  • Generic Responses: Saying things like “This company is well-known” or “I need a job” without specifics.
  • Focusing on Benefits: Mentioning salary, perks, or vacation time as primary motivators.
  • Lack of Research: Showing no knowledge of the company’s values, products, or recent news.

How to Nail It

Do Your Research:
Know their mission, values, and key projects. Mention specifics that resonate with you.

Align Their Goals With Yours:
Explain how your aspirations fit the company’s direction.

Show Team Spirit:
Express enthusiasm for working with like-minded people in a collaborative environment.

#3 “Describe a time when you dealt with a challenge or solved a hard problem.”

What’s Behind the Question?

  • The manager wants to see how you approach and solve complex problems.
  • They’re gauging your ability to communicate challenges clearly, especially to non-experts.
  • They’re looking for resilience, teamwork, and adaptability.

Common Mistakes

  • Being Vague or Overly General: Providing a broad answer without specific details makes it hard for the interviewer to gauge your problem-solving skills.
  • Choosing an Irrelevant Example: Discussing a challenge that doesn’t relate to the job you’re applying for misses an opportunity to showcase relevant skills.
  • Not Explaining the Outcome: Failing to mention the results of your actions leaves the story incomplete.

How to Nail It

Follow the STAR Method:
  • Situation: Set the scene briefly.
  • Task: Define the problem or goal.
  • Action: Explain the steps you took to address it.
  • Result: Highlight the positive outcome, with measurable results if possible.
Emphasize the Process:
Show how you thought critically and involved others when necessary.

Choose Relevant Examples:
Highlight scenarios that demonstrate skills crucial to the role.

#4 “What are your strengths and weaknesses?”

What’s Behind the Question?

  • They want to know if you’re self-aware and open to improvement.
  • Strengths reveal how well your skills align with the job.
  • Weaknesses test your honesty and how you handle challenges.

Common Mistakes

  • Listing Irrelevant Strengths: Mentioning strengths that don’t align with the job requirements misses the chance to prove you’re a good fit.
  • Revealing Critical Weaknesses: Admitting to a weakness that is a key requirement for the job raises red flags.
  • Not Explaining How You’re Addressing Weaknesses: Failing to show that you’re proactive about self-improvement.

How to Nail It

Highlight Strengths With Evidence:
Share specific achievements that back up your claims.

Be Honest About Weaknesses:
Choose a real area of improvement, but emphasize steps you’re taking to grow.

Avoid Clichés:
Skip generic answers like “I’m a perfectionist.” Be genuine and relatable.

# 5 “Do you have any questions for us?”

What’s Behind the Question?

  • They’re testing your preparation and engagement.
  • Insightful questions demonstrate curiosity, critical thinking, and genuine interest.
  • This is also your chance to make a strong final impression.

Common Mistakes

  • Saying “No, I think you’ve covered everything”: This response can signal a lack of interest or enthusiasm.
  • Asking Questions with Obvious Answers: Inquiring about information easily found on the company’s website shows a lack of preparation.
  • Focusing Solely on Yourself: Questions like “How soon can I be promoted?” may come across as self-centered.

How to Nail It

Ask About Success and Impact:
“What does success look like in this role over the first six months?”

Show Long-Term Interest:
“How does the company support professional development?”

Be Strategic:
“What’s the most exciting challenge your team is tackling right now?”

Avoid Self-Centered Questions:
Skip topics like salary or perks unless prompted by the interviewer.

Final Thoughts: Turning the Tables

Recognizing where you might be going wrong is the first step to getting it right. These questions are common stumbling blocks, but with the right approach, you can turn them into stepping stones toward your dream job. By avoiding typical mistakes and demonstrating genuine enthusiasm, clear thinking, and a growth mindset, you’ll stand out as the candidate they want to work with. Now, go ace that interview!

This is barely scratching the surface… - Want more?

The strategies we’ve shared here are just the tip of the iceberg. These are the very basics — your starting point. But there is so much more to learn. We’ve conducted hundreds of interviews, and we know the shortcuts and secrets hiring managers use to assess candidates in minutes.

We’ll show you exactly how to:
  • Decode the hidden cues that hiring managers are looking for.
  • Avoid common mistakes that disqualify even great candidates.
  • Answer tough questions with confidence and authenticity.

You don’t have to navigate this alone. We’ll give you all the tools you need to exceed expectations and leave a lasting impression.

💡 Your future is worth investing in. Join our Job Interview Excellence course today. With over 12 premium videos, interactive AI coaching, and insider knowledge, you’ll gain the skills to not just meet but exceed hiring managers’ expectations.
Don’t let your dream job slip away.
Created with